Godfather’s has five desserts and every one of them is worth knowing about. Warm monkey bread, cinnamon streusel, a big chocolate chip cookie — here’s what to order and what it costs.
Most people don’t plan on getting dessert. Then the Cinnamon Monkey Bread shows up warm and gooey and everybody’s fighting over the last piece. It happens at almost every table. The dessert menu here is short but there’s nothing throwaway on it — every item earns its spot. For the full picture on what we’re serving, hit the full menu page.
Every Dessert, Ranked
#1 — Cinnamon Monkey Bread ($7.79)
Warm pull-apart sweet bread coated in cinnamon sugar with an icing drizzle. $7.79. This is the one we’d order every time if we had to pick one. The pull-apart format is half the experience — everyone reaches in, it’s warm and soft in the middle, and the icing drizzle is just enough sweetness without being overwhelming. If you’ve made the streusel recipe at home, you already know the flavor profile we’re working with here.
Verdict: The best dessert on the menu. Order it every time.
#2 — Caramel Monkey Bread ($7.79)
Same pull-apart format as the Cinnamon, but topped with caramel instead of icing. Also $7.79. Slightly richer and a little less sweet than the cinnamon version. If your group is split on preferences, ordering one Cinnamon and one Caramel is the right call — they’re different enough to offer variety, same price, and together they feed a big table through dessert without anyone going without.
Verdict: Nearly as good as the Cinnamon. The caramel flavor is richer and pairs well with a pizza night that already had a lot going on.
#3 — Dessert Streusels ($7.79–$12.24)
Cinnamon-sugar topped dessert with a sweet glaze. Small is $7.79, large is $12.24. The streusel portions more cleanly than monkey bread — if you’ve got people who want a defined portion rather than sharing from a communal pull-apart, this is the better pick. The large handles a bigger group and prices out better per serving than the small.
Verdict: Great for groups that want clean portions. Get the large if you’ve got more than four people.
#4 — Big Chocolate Chip Cookie ($7.79)
Fresh-baked chocolate chip cookie. Six servings. $7.79. Simple, reliable, and always a hit with kids. There are no gimmicks here — it’s a warm cookie with chocolate chips and that’s exactly what it’s supposed to be. Best order when you’ve got younger kids at the table who want dessert without anything too adventurous.
Verdict: The crowd-pleaser default. Not the most exciting dessert but the most universally liked.
#5 — Italian Monkey Bread ($7.79)
Garlic butter, seasoned cheese, served with marinara. $7.79. This one lives in the dessert category but it eats like a savory side — think garlic bread in pull-apart form. It’s listed here because it’s technically a dessert menu item, but it’s really the call for people who don’t want something sweet. Order it mid-meal instead of at the end if your group is skipping sweet dessert entirely.
Verdict: Savory, surprising, and good. Best ordered when your group wants the pull-apart experience but nobody’s in the mood for sugar.
Dessert Pricing
Cinnamon Monkey Bread: $7.79
Caramel Monkey Bread: $7.79
Italian Monkey Bread: $7.79
Big Chocolate Chip Cookie: $7.79
Dessert Streusels (Small): $7.79 | (Large): $12.24
Best for Sharing
All five desserts are designed to share. That said, some work better for big tables than others.
For groups of 4–6 people, the Dessert Streusel large ($12.24) or two monkey breads ($7.79 each) are the call — you get enough to go around without anyone feeling shorted. For smaller groups or families with young kids, one monkey bread and the Big Cookie covers the table. The pull-apart format of the monkey breads encourages sharing in a way that makes dessert feel like part of the meal, not an afterthought.
Ordering for a bigger group? Our catering packages can include dessert — call us to discuss what makes sense for your event size. And check out sides ranked if you’re still building out the rest of the order.
FAQ
What’s the most popular dessert at Godfather’s?
The Cinnamon Monkey Bread is our most ordered dessert. It’s warm, pull-apart, and $7.79. The Caramel Monkey Bread is a close second — same format, richer flavor. Both are worth trying if you’ve never had them.
What’s the difference between the monkey breads?
There are three: Cinnamon ($7.79, cinnamon sugar with icing drizzle), Caramel ($7.79, caramel topping), and Italian ($7.79, garlic butter and seasoned cheese with marinara). The Cinnamon and Caramel are sweet desserts. The Italian is savory — it’s basically garlic bread in pull-apart form.
How many people does a dessert serve?
Each monkey bread and the Big Cookie are sized for 4–6 people as a shared dessert. The Dessert Streusel small handles 2–4, the large handles 6+. For big groups we’d recommend two items — mix and match based on what your table wants.
Can I add dessert to a catering order?
Yes. Call us at (210) 750-2222 to add desserts to any catering order. We’ll make sure you have enough for your group. The monkey breads and streusel are the most popular catering dessert choices.
