Valentine’s Day Date Ideas: Godfather’s Pizza San Antonio

Why Pizza Works for Valentine’s Day

Hear us out. A crowded steakhouse with a prix fixe menu and 45-minute wait isn’t romantic — it’s stressful. Pizza is warm, shareable, and exactly what you actually want to eat. Godfather’s gives you something to look forward to instead of something to survive.

We’ve been back in San Antonio for a few years now, Veteran-Owned and west-side proud. When Valentine’s Day rolls around, we see a lot of couples do it right: a great pizza, good sides, maybe a dessert to split. Simple beats complicated every time. Check out our full menu to start planning your order.

Valentine’s pizza also travels. You’re not tied to a table or a reservation. You can order delivery, pick it up, take it to a park, bring it to a friend’s rooftop, or eat it on your couch in your pajamas watching something you both actually want to watch. Nobody’s going to rush you out for the next seating. That’s a real win.

Three Ways to Do Valentine’s Day at Godfather’s

Dine-In for Two

Come in together. You get the pizza fresh out of the oven, you’re not doing dishes, and you can actually relax. Our west-side spot is laid-back and low-pressure — exactly the vibe you want on a weeknight holiday. A medium specialty pizza is plenty for two people with sides to share.

Delivery at Home

Set the table, light a candle, put on a movie. We deliver to your door so you can skip the parking situation entirely. Order ahead so it arrives when you’re ready — don’t wait until you’re already hungry.

Picnic or Park Night

San Antonio weather in February can surprise you. If it’s a nice evening, pick up your order and head to a park. Pizza travels well. Pack the box, grab some napkins, and you’ve got a date night that cost you a fraction of a restaurant and twice the fun.

What to Order for Two

You want something that’s easy to share and actually tastes like a treat. Here’s what we’d recommend for a Valentine’s order for two:

The Humble Pie is a solid pick — Signature Sauce, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, and Mozzarella. It’s a well-built pizza that doesn’t try to be everything at once. Medium size runs $20.99 and feeds two people comfortably. Read about your crust options to pick what you want underneath it — Golden if you like a little crunch, Original if you want the classic.

If you’d rather let each person pick their half, the Half & Half Specialty Pie lets you do exactly that. Two different specialty pizzas on one pie — medium starts at $21.99. No compromise, no arguing over toppings.

We also have a full breakdown of our top picks if you want to see how the whole lineup stacks up before you decide.

Valentine’s Pizzas Worth Knowing About

Beyond the Humble Pie and the Half & Half, there are a few other specialty options that are good for a date night order. The Chicken Bacon Ranch (Ranch Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Mozzarella — $13.99–$34.50) is a crowd favorite for people who want something different from a traditional red-sauce pizza. The BBQ Chicken is another solid option for anyone who wants sweet and smoky over savory.

If the two of you can’t agree on a pizza style, order a Create Your Own — choose your sauce, your toppings, your crust, done. Medium starts at $15.99 and up depending on toppings. You each pick half, you both win. That’s the spirit of Valentine’s Day right there.

Round It Out with Sides

Sides turn a pizza order into a full meal. For a Valentine’s night, here’s what we’d add:

• Cheesesticks — garlic, Italian seasoning, mozzarella, with marinara. $7.79 small, $12.24 large. Great for sharing.
• Garlic Bread with Cheese — $7.79, warm, buttery, done right.
• Side Salad or Garden Salad — keeps it balanced. Side for $5.99, garden for $8.99.

See the full rundown on our sides if you want to see how everything compares.

Don’t Skip Dessert

This is Valentine’s Day — you need a dessert. We’ve got a few good ones:

Dessert Streusels ($7.79–$12.24) are warm, cinnamon-sugar topped, and sweet without being over the top. Split one between two people and it’s just right. The Cinnamon Monkey Bread ($7.79) is pull-apart warm bread with cinnamon sugar and icing drizzle — it disappears fast. Big, sweet, and meant to be shared.

If you’re the kind of couple that fights over the last piece of chocolate chip cookie, the Big Chocolate Chip Cookie ($7.79) is six servings of fresh-baked goodness. Nobody’s going home hungry.

Planning to go bigger? If you’re combining Valentine’s dinner with a larger gathering, our catering options have you covered for parties of any size.

How Much to Order

For two people, a medium specialty pizza plus one side and one dessert is the right call. You’ll both eat well without over-ordering and ending up with half a pizza in the fridge. Here’s a simple breakdown:

• Light appetite: Medium specialty + side salad + dessert streusel (small). ~$35
• Normal appetite: Medium specialty + cheesesticks (small) + dessert streusel (small). ~$36
• Hungry: Large specialty + cheesesticks (large) + Cinnamon Monkey Bread. ~$55

If you’re doing delivery, add 15–20 minutes to your estimate and order before you’re hungry. Nobody makes great ordering decisions when they’re already starving and impatient.

How to Set Up a Great Valentine’s Pizza Night

A few things that make the difference:

• Order 30–45 minutes ahead. Valentine’s Day is busy. Don’t wait until 7pm to start thinking about dinner.
• Pick your crust intentionally. Golden crust holds up better for delivery. Original if you’re eating it right away at the shop.
• Add a dessert to the order. You’re already ordering — the monkey bread is a no-brainer add-on.
• Plates and candles optional. The box is already romantic enough.

Want to see everything available for a date night in? We wrote up a whole guide to date night orders at Godfather’s — worth a quick read before you finalize your order.

Frequently Asked Questions