Good pizza for under $20 in San Antonio isn’t a fantasy — we’ve got plenty of it. From a classic Cheese Pizza at $7.99 to medium specialty pies and our best mid-week deal, Godfather’s Pizza delivers real food at prices that don’t require a second thought. Here’s exactly what to order when the budget matters.
Cheese and Pepperoni: The Under-$10 Stars
If you want pizza for under $10, a Mini or Small Cheese Pizza starts at $7.99. That’s Signature Sauce and Mozzarella on your choice of crust — simple, fast, and exactly what it needs to be. A Small Pepperoni starts at $9.99 and adds our classic pepperoni on top. Either one works as a solo lunch or a quick dinner when you’re not feeding a crowd.
Check out our full menu for the complete size and pricing breakdown on every pizza we make. Small sizes are great if you want to try something new without committing to a large pie.
For the best value per slice, a Medium Cheese or Pepperoni pizza is where the math tips in your favor. You get more pizza per dollar than the small, and a Medium feeds two people comfortably without pushing past the $20 mark.
Medium Specialty Pies Around $17-$18
Here’s where it gets interesting. A Medium specialty pizza — any of them — starts at $13.99. That means our Classic Combo (Pepperoni, Beef, Sausage, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Onions on Signature Sauce) or the Humble Pie (Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions) comes in well under $20 in a medium. Eight toppings for under $20 is hard to beat anywhere on the west side.
Our cheap pizza picks break down which specialty pies give you the most topping value for the money. The All-Meat Combo and Classic Combo are consistently at the top of that list.
Feasts: More Food, Better Value
If you’re feeding more than two people, the Feasts section of our menu changes the math entirely. The Build Your Own Feast (Mediums) — a Medium Specialty Pizza, a Medium 1-Topping Pizza, and a side — comes in at $35.99. That feeds 4-6 people, which works out to under $10 per person.
That’s not technically “under $20” for one pizza, but it’s under $20 per person when you’re splitting it with the family. Our family deals page covers the full feast lineup with all the combinations so you can plan before you order.
The Pizza Pack is another one worth knowing: four Medium 1-Topping Pizzas for $60, feeding 8-12 people. That’s $15 per pizza. If you’re ordering for a team, a group hangout, or a birthday party on a budget, that’s your deal.
The Mid-Week MVP: $8 Off on Mon, Wed, and Fri
Our biggest regular deal is the Save $8 Mon-Wed deal — $8 off a Large pizza on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. A Large Specialty Pizza normally starts at around $25.99. Take $8 off that and you’re at $17.99 for a Large Classic Combo, All-Meat Combo, Taco Pie — whatever you want. That’s a Large loaded pizza for under $20, mid-week.
If you’re working from home or on a tight week, planning your pizza night around Mon, Wed, or Fri is the move. It’s the best per-slice deal we run on a regular basis.
See all our current deals to make sure you’re not leaving any savings on the table before you order. We run specials that rotate, and the deals page stays current.
What About Crust — Does It Affect Price?
Short answer: no, crust choice doesn’t change the price of the pizza. Whether you go Original (thick and chewy), Golden (buttery pan-style), or Thin, you’re paying the same for the pizza itself. So if you want to make your under-$20 pizza feel a little more special, go Golden crust — it’s a free upgrade in texture.
Our crust options page covers the full breakdown if you haven’t tried all five. First-timers on a budget should try Golden crust on a Medium specialty — you’ll get a lot of pizza for the money.
| Pizza | Starting Price | Size |
|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza | $7.99 | Mini |
| Pepperoni Pizza | $9.99 | Mini |
| Any Specialty Pizza (Medium) | $13.99–$19.99 | Medium |
| Large Specialty (w/ $8 deal) | ~$17.99 | Large |
| Build Your Own Feast (Mediums) | $35.99 (feeds 4–6) | Feast |
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the cheapest pizza at Godfather’s Pizza San Antonio?
A Mini or Small Cheese Pizza starts at $7.99. That’s Signature Sauce and Mozzarella — the most basic, most affordable pizza on the menu. Pepperoni starts at $9.99. Both are solid options when you just need something quick and inexpensive.
What’s the best deal on a specialty pizza under $20?
Any Medium specialty pizza starts at $13.99 and comes in well under $20. That includes the Classic Combo, Humble Pie, Taco Pie, All-Meat Combo — eight loaded toppings for under $20 is the best bang for your buck in San Antonio. On Mon, Wed, and Fri, you can get a Large for around $17.99 with our $8-off deal.
Does Godfather’s Pizza San Antonio have any regular weekly deals?
Yes — we take $8 off Large pizzas on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. It’s the best ongoing deal we run. A Large specialty pizza on those days comes in under $20. Check our deals page for any other rotating specials before you order.
What’s the best value for feeding a family of four for under $20 per person?
The Build Your Own Feast (Mediums) at $35.99 feeds 4-6 people and includes a Medium Specialty Pizza, a Medium 1-Topping Pizza, and a side. That works out to under $10 per person. It’s the best family meal deal we have.
Do different crust options cost more?
No — crust choice doesn’t change the price of the pizza. Original, Golden, Thin, Mozzarella Loaded, and Parmesan all cost the same for the same size. Pick whatever crust you like best without worrying about the price.
Ready to order? Pick your pizza, pick your crust, and get it going. We’re on 151 and always ready.
