If you love that buffalo heat on wings, our Buffalo Chicken pizza review is the pizza version of that same flavor profile — same heat, built into every bite of a specialty pie.
Godfather’s wings are the reason a lot of people turn a pizza order into a full spread. Bone-in or boneless, three sauce choices, half or full — here’s everything you need to know before you order.
The pizza gets the headline. The wings get the repeat business. That’s not an accident — we take the wings as seriously as the pies, and the people who’ve tried them know it. Whether you’re planning a game night or just need something to put on the table while the pizza finishes, the wings are the call. For a look at everything else we’re working with, the full menu has the complete picture.
Bone-In vs. Boneless — Which One?
Both options run the same price: $16.49 for a half order, $26.49 for a full. The half is right for two or three people as a side. The full is what you want when wings are the centerpiece or you’ve got four or more people at the table.
Bone-in wings have more flavor and a better texture from the bone — if you’ve got the patience to eat them, they’re the better wing. Boneless is the call for kids, for people who want to eat fast, or for anyone who’d rather not deal with bones mid-bite. Either way you get the same sauce options and the same dipping choices (ranch or blue cheese).
Not sure what else to add to the order? The sides ranked guide breaks down where wings sit against everything else on the menu.
Sauce Breakdown
Buffalo
The most ordered sauce we have. Classic buffalo — tangy, medium heat, and built to pair with ranch or blue cheese. If your group has one or two heat-cautious people, this is still the safe pick because it’s not a face-melter. It’s the wing sauce most people are expecting, and it delivers every time.
BBQ
The better call for mixed groups. Sweeter, smokier, and no heat — BBQ works across the table whether you’ve got kids, heat-sensitive adults, or people who just prefer the flavor profile. Pairs better with ranch than blue cheese. This is the one we’d order for a group where you can’t get a consensus on the buffalo.
Naked
No sauce — just the wing, seasoned and baked. This is the underrated option. Get naked wings and order an extra dipping sauce on the side ($0.99 each). You control the sauce ratio that way, and if you’re a buffalo person, you can dip heavy. Good call for people who want the wing without the mess or who prefer a lighter flavor.
Wing Pricing at a Glance
Bone-In Half: $16.49 | Bone-In Full: $26.49
Boneless Half: $16.49 | Boneless Full: $26.49
Sauce choices: Naked, Buffalo, BBQ
Served with ranch or blue cheese
Best Pizza Pairings
Wings and pizza together is the move, but not every pizza pairs the same way. Here’s what works:
Buffalo wings + All-Meat Combo or Classic Combo: The tang from the buffalo cuts through the richness of the meat pizza. This is the combination most of our regulars land on. For crust recommendations on the Combo, check our top pizzas guide.
BBQ wings + Hawaiian or BBQ Chicken: Double BBQ sounds like too much but it isn’t — the wing sauce and the pizza sauce are different enough that it works. This is a sweet, smoky spread that plays well on a Friday night.
Naked wings + Taco Pie: The Taco Pie is already full of bold flavor. Naked wings keep the side from competing. Add extra ranch and let the pizza be the star.
Planning a bigger event? Our catering packages include the Pizza and Wing Feast — a specialty pizza, a 1-topping pizza, and a full order of wings. The medium version is $45.99, large is $55.99. Call us to set it up.
Wings + Movie Night
The wings and pizza combo is a natural fit for staying in — and we’ve built a whole order recommendation around it. The movie night combo guide has the full breakdown: what to order, how much to get, and how to time everything so it all arrives hot at the same time.
FAQ
How many wings come in a half vs. full order?
We serve by half and full order — the half is right for 2–3 people as a side, the full handles 4 or more. Both bone-in and boneless run $16.49 for a half and $26.49 for a full. Add wings to any pizza order at checkout or call us to add them to a catering order.
Are the wings baked or fried?
Baked. That’s how Godfather’s does wings — baked, not fried. You get a good texture without the grease of deep-frying. The sauce goes on after baking so it stays clean and doesn’t get absorbed away during cooking.
Can I get more than one sauce on an order?
The standard order comes with one sauce choice. If you want variety, your best bet is to order two half orders with different sauces — that’s $32.98 total and gives you a half of each. Call us at (210) 750-2222 if you have a specific request and we’ll see what we can do.
Do the wings come with a dipping sauce?
Yes — every wing order comes with ranch or blue cheese. If you want extra dipping sauces, they’re $0.99 each and worth it, especially with naked wings where you’re building your own flavor ratio.
