Can’t pick one pizza? Don’t. The Half & Half lets you put two different specialty pies on the same crust — problem solved, no arguments at the table. Here’s how it works, what to put on it, and when it’s the smartest order you can make.
How Half & Half Works
We offer two versions of the Half & Half. Both let you split a pizza down the middle and put two different specialty builds on each side.
The Half & Half Specialty Pie uses two different specialty pizzas from our standard specialty menu — Classic Combo, Taco Pie, Bacon Cheeseburger, Hawaiian, Veggie, Hot Stuff, Humble Pie, Chicken Bacon Ranch, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, or Banana Pepper & Sausage Trio. It’s available Small, Medium, and Large, running $21.99 to $35.99.
The Half & Half Super Specialty Pie uses two different Super Specialty pizzas — the Super Combo, Super Taco, or combinations from that tier. It runs $15.99 to $37.75. Check the full menu to see every pizza in each tier before you order.
One thing to note: Half & Half isn’t available on Mini. You need at least a Small to split the pizza into two distinct halves. At Small size, each half gives you 3 slices. At Large, each half gives you 4 slices — which is plenty for two people to get their own preference.
Best Combos to Put on a Half & Half
Some combinations on a Half & Half just work. Others clash. Here’s what we’ve seen order well:
Taco Pie + Classic Combo — This is the most popular Half & Half order we see. The Taco Pie is our most-ordered pizza. The Classic Combo is the reliable crowd-pleaser. Put them on the same pie and you’ve handled the whole table. The flavors are distinct enough that each half stands alone — the taco sauce on one side doesn’t bleed into the Signature Sauce on the other in a way that ruins either. See our top 5 pizzas for why both of these are on the list.
Hawaiian + Hot Stuff — Sweet and savory on one side, spicy and loaded on the other. This is the combo for a household where tastes genuinely don’t overlap. The Hawaiian has pineapple, ham, and bacon on Signature Sauce. The Hot Stuff has pepperoni, beef, Italian sausage, jalapeños, and onions. They’re two completely different flavor experiences on one pie, which is the whole point of Half & Half. If you want to explore what else works well, our build your own combos guide has ideas for mixing flavor profiles.
Humble Pie + Bacon Cheeseburger — Two underrated specialty pizzas, each with a distinct personality. The Humble Pie is pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, and onions — clean, classic, reliable. The Bacon Cheeseburger is beef, bacon, pickles, and cheddar — weird in the best way. Together they give you a half that feels like a classic pizza night and a half that feels like an experiment. They’re compared directly in our Humble Pie vs Classic Combo breakdown if you want more detail on what makes each one tick.
Veggie + All-Meat Combo — The obvious family play. The vegetarians get their side. The meat eaters get theirs. Nobody orders something they don’t want. This is the order that ends the pizza debate before it starts, which is why we mention it every time a family calls to ask what to get. Our take on why kids and adults both happy covers more on how to structure an order for mixed groups.
Perfect for Families with Different Tastes
The Half & Half exists specifically for this situation. Two kids who want different things. Parents who don’t agree on toppings. A spouse who wants meat and a partner who wants vegetables. You don’t need to order two whole pizzas — you need one Half & Half and a side of breadsticks, and everyone’s covered.
For groups of 4–6, a Large Half & Half plus another Large pizza handles the table. For smaller groups or couples with different tastes, a Medium Half & Half is the right call — four slices per side means two people each get their preferred pizza without anything going to waste.
Available Sizes and Crust Options
Half & Half is available in Small, Medium, and Large. Not Mini — the split doesn’t work at that size. Crust options are the same as any pizza: Golden, Original, or Thin. The crust applies to the whole pie, so you’re both getting the same base. Our crust options page explains the differences if you haven’t figured out which one you prefer.
Golden crust is rich and buttery — good when both halves are heavy on cheese or meat. Original is the classic thick crust, solid for anything. Thin is the move when you want a lighter result or when one of your halves is vegetable-forward.
Half & Half Specialty Pie — $21.99 to $35.99
Two different specialty pizzas on one pie. Small, Medium, Large.
Half & Half Super Specialty Pie — $15.99 to $37.75
Two different Super Specialty pizzas on one pie. Small, Medium, Large.
How to Order It
When you order online, you’ll select the Half & Half option and then choose your two pizzas. When you call, just tell us “Half & Half” and name your two choices. We’ll make sure the line stays clean down the middle — each half gets its own toppings, sauce, and cheese. The crust runs the full pie, so both sides bake together.
If you’re not sure what to put on each half, trust the Taco Pie + Classic Combo combination. It works every time. We’ve been making that one since we opened on 151, and it’s still the first thing we recommend when someone calls and says they can’t decide.
What sizes are available for Half & Half pizza at Godfather’s?
Half & Half is available in Small, Medium, and Large. It’s not available on Mini — the split doesn’t work at that size. At Large, each half gives you 4 slices, which comfortably feeds two people per side.
What’s the difference between Half & Half Specialty and Half & Half Super Specialty?
Half & Half Specialty ($21.99–$35.99) lets you choose two pizzas from our standard specialty menu. Half & Half Super Specialty ($15.99–$37.75) lets you choose two pizzas from our Super Specialty tier (Super Combo, Super Taco). The Super Specialty tier has more toppings, which is why the pricing range extends higher.
Can I do a Half & Half with one specialty and one super specialty pizza?
No — each Half & Half option stays within its tier. The Specialty Half & Half uses two specialty pizzas, and the Super Specialty Half & Half uses two Super Specialty pizzas. If you want one from each tier, you’d need to order two separate pizzas.
Does the sauce mix between the two halves on a Half & Half?
There’s a natural boundary down the middle of the pizza, but the sauces are close to the line. If both halves use Signature Sauce, there’s no issue. If you’re putting Taco Sauce on one side and Signature Sauce on the other, there may be a little mixing right at the seam — nothing that ruins the pizza.
What’s the most popular Half & Half combination at Godfather’s?
Taco Pie + Classic Combo is the most common. The Taco Pie is our most-ordered pizza overall, and the Classic Combo is the most reliable crowd-pleaser — putting both on a Half & Half handles the whole table without any compromises.
