If neither the Classic Combo nor the All Meat grabs you, the Banana Pepper and Sausage Trio is a specialty build worth exploring. Our Banana Pepper Sausage Trio pizza guide explains what sets it apart from the standard meat lineup.
Both the Classic Combo and the All-Meat Combo run $13.99–$34.50. Both pile on seven toppings. But they eat completely differently — one is a balanced pizza with vegetables, the other is a wall-to-wall meat situation. Here’s which one to order and when.
We get this question more than you’d think. Two of our most popular specialty pizzas, same price point, but totally different experiences. The Classic Combo review gets into the details on one side. This post puts them head-to-head so you can actually decide before you order.
The Classic Combo — What’s On It?
The Classic Combo loads up with Signature Sauce, pepperoni, beef, sausage, black olives, mushrooms, onions, and mozzarella. That’s seven toppings across three meats and four vegetables. It’s a complete pizza — you get savory protein, earthy mushrooms, the bite of onion, and the mellowing effect of black olives all in one slice.
It’s the pizza you order when everyone at the table has different preferences and you need one pizza that checks every box. Nobody’s going to pick the mushrooms off. Well, almost nobody.
The All-Meat Combo — What’s On It?
The All-Meat Combo is exactly what it sounds like. Signature Sauce, ham, pepperoni, bacon, beef, Italian sausage, sausage, and mozzarella. Six meats. Zero vegetables. This is the All-Meat Combo cheat day pizza — dense, heavy, no apologies. The combo of ham, bacon, and three types of sausage means every bite has a different texture and smokiness going on.
It’s a lot of pizza in the best possible way. If you’ve got serious meat eaters at the table — or you’re just not in the mood for vegetables — this is the move.
Topping Count and Coverage
Classic Combo: 3 meats + 4 vegetables = 7 toppings total.
All-Meat Combo: 6 meats + 0 vegetables = 6 toppings total — but meats are heavier by weight, so the All-Meat Combo generally has more topping coverage per square inch.
Bacon and ham in particular add volume. When you layer six proteins together, you’re looking at a pizza where the toppings are sometimes thicker than the crust itself. That’s especially true on the Medium and Large. Our meat lover’s guide goes deep on how we build these.
Classic Combo: 7 toppings (3 meats, 4 veggies)
All-Meat Combo: 6 toppings (6 meats, 0 veggies)
Both: $13.99 Mini → $34.50 Large
Both available in all four sizes on any crust style
Pricing: Same Range, Same Sizes
Both pizzas start at $13.99 for a Mini and go up to $34.50 for a Large. Both are available in Mini, Small, Medium, and Large. You’re not paying extra for the All-Meat Combo despite the heavier topping load — that’s the deal.
The top 5 pizzas post ranks both of these, but the honest answer is they’re neck and neck for our best sellers. It comes down to who you’re feeding.
Crust Pick for Each
Classic Combo pairs best with Original crust — the thickness balances the mixed toppings without any one flavor dominating. The All-Meat Combo goes well on Golden crust, where the buttery, pan-style base adds richness that complements the heavier protein load. That said, both work on any of our crust options — you can’t really go wrong.
The Verdict
If “bigger” means more topping weight, the All-Meat Combo edges it out. If “bigger” means more variety per slice, Classic Combo wins on breadth. Most tables are better served by the Classic Combo unless everyone at the table explicitly wants meat-only. For a mixed crowd or a group that includes lighter eaters, Classic Combo is the safer call.
Want to look at the full menu before you decide? Fair. Everything is on there — including every size and price.
FAQ
Is the All-Meat Combo heavier than the Classic Combo?
Yes, by total topping weight. Six meats — including bacon and ham — outweigh the three meats plus vegetables on the Classic Combo. You’ll notice the difference especially on a Large. It’s a denser slice.
Can I get both combos on thin crust?
Yes, but thin crust is only available in Medium and Large. If you’re going thin with either combo, Medium is a good call — the toppings to crust ratio holds up better. On thin with the All-Meat especially, you’ll want to give it a minute to set before lifting a slice.
Do both combos cost the same?
Yes — both start at $13.99 (Mini) and go up to $34.50 (Large). The All-Meat Combo does not cost more despite having more protein. Same pricing tier as every other specialty pizza.
What’s the difference between sausage and Italian sausage on the All-Meat Combo?
Regular sausage is our standard pizza sausage — mildly seasoned, slightly crumbled. Italian sausage is coarser, fennel-forward, and more distinctly savory. Having both on the same pizza gives you different textures and flavors in the same bite. It’s one of the things that makes the All-Meat Combo stand out from a generic meat pizza.
Which pizza is better for a group?
Classic Combo for a mixed group — the vegetable toppings make it more broadly appealing. All-Meat Combo for a table of confirmed carnivores or a post-game crowd that wants maximum protein. If you’re not sure, the Classic Combo is the safer group order.
