If you’re already adding sides to your order and want to round it out with something lighter, we do offer salads too. Our pizza salads guide covers all the options and what each one includes.
Godfather’s potato wedges are seasoned, baked golden, and $6.74. They’re the utility side that doesn’t get enough credit — here’s what you get, what to dip them in, and why they’re worth adding to your order.
Potato wedges aren’t the most exciting thing on the menu, but they might be the most underrated. At $6.74 they’re the cheapest hot side we carry, they hold heat better than most sides, and they work for everyone at the table — including the people who don’t want cheesesticks or wings. The sides ranked guide slots them at #5, which feels right — solid, reliable, never a mistake.
What You Get
One order of potato wedges, seasoned and baked golden. $6.74. There’s no complicated description needed — these are exactly what they sound like: thick-cut potatoes with a good seasoning blend, cooked until they’re crispy on the outside and tender in the middle.
The baked preparation means they’re not greasy. You get the satisfaction of a potato side without the heaviness that fried wedges can add to an already-loaded pizza order. They come out of the oven hot and they stay warm longer than breadsticks or cheesesticks — useful if your order is taking the full trip across the west side.
Potato Wedges
Seasoned, baked golden
Price: $6.74
Best Dipping Sauces
The potato wedges don’t come with a designated dipping sauce, so add one. Ranch is $0.99 and it’s the move — creamy, herby, and the classic wedge dip. Blue cheese works if you’re already ordering wings and have some on the table. Marinara is surprisingly good if you want to stay in the pizza flavor profile.
If you’re ordering wings alongside the wedges, share the ranch or blue cheese — you’re already getting it for the wings, so the wedges come along for free on the dipping sauce front.
Worth the Add-On?
Yes, especially for groups of four or more where you want something on the table to tide people over while the pizza is finishing. Wedges fill a gap that the cheesier sides don’t — they’re good for the people at the table who want something starchy and filling without more dairy.
They’re also the best pairing for our richer pizzas. The Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza with a side of potato wedges is the combination that makes the most sense — it’s a burger and fries on pizza terms. Same logic applies to the Classic Combo or All-Meat when you want something that grounds a heavy meat pizza.
For the full rundown on every side option, check our menu. And while you’re building the order, see what our breadsticks are about — at $6.99 they’re a good complement to the wedges if you want variety. Looking at what’s worth ordering overall? The top pizzas page also covers the best side pairings by pie.
How the Wedges Fit Into a Larger Order
For a standard family order — say, two pizzas and a couple of sides — potato wedges and cheesesticks together are the right move. The cheesesticks handle the cheesy, shareable starter role. The wedges give people something to keep eating between slices, especially the kids at the table who want something other than pizza crust. At $6.74 for wedges and $7.79 for small cheesesticks, you’re at $14.53 for both — that’s a solid sides spread for under $15.
For bigger groups, consider ordering two orders of wedges. They hold heat well, they go fast, and at $13.48 for two you’re feeding a full table of people for less than a medium pizza. That’s the value play nobody talks about enough. If you’re putting together a catering order and want to include wedges, call us at (210) 750-2222 — we’ll make sure the quantities work for your headcount.
What Makes Them Different from Fries
Potato wedges aren’t fries. The wedge cut means more potato per piece — you get a thicker, meatier bite with more interior softness under the crispy exterior. They’re more filling than fries, they hold their temperature better, and they don’t go limp the way thin-cut fries do when they sit for a few minutes. If you’re picking up in-store or the delivery has a bit of distance on it, wedges survive the ride better than anything else in the sides lineup.
That durability is part of why we went with wedges over fries. On the west side, a lot of our orders are delivery or pickup for people coming from Westover Hills, Alamo Ranch, and out past 151. The wedges make the trip without losing texture. That matters when you’re trying to feed a hungry crew.
FAQ
Are the potato wedges fried or baked?
Baked. We don’t deep-fry them — they’re seasoned and baked golden in the oven. You get crispy edges and a tender inside without the grease. It’s the same philosophy we apply to our wings.
How many people does one order of wedges feed?
As a side alongside pizza, one order of potato wedges works for 2–4 people. If you’ve got a bigger group and want everyone to have plenty, order two. At $6.74 each it’s an easy add. For larger events, call us about catering — we can include wedges in the sides spread.
What sauce comes with the potato wedges?
No sauce comes automatically — but dipping sauces are $0.99 each. Ranch is the most popular choice. Marinara also works well. If you’re already ordering wings, share the dipping sauce that comes with those.
Are potato wedges a good option for picky eaters?
Yes — they’re cheese-free, not spicy, and familiar to almost everyone. Potato wedges are the reliable call when you’ve got a mixed group including kids or anyone who isn’t into the cheesier or spicier options on the sides menu.
