Is There Actually a Secret Menu?
Straight answer: no. Godfather’s doesn’t have a hidden menu with items that aren’t listed anywhere. Anyone who tells you otherwise is making things up.
What we do have is a full menu packed with more flexibility than most people realize — crust choices, sauce swaps, half-and-half options, add-ons, and specialty combos that a lot of customers walk right past. That’s where the “secrets” live. Not in some mythical off-menu item, but in knowing how to work what’s already there.
Insider Trick 1: Double Sauce on Thin Crust
Thin crust is the most underrated option we offer. It’s crispy, it cooks fast, and it holds toppings without getting soggy. But the one thing people miss: standard sauce coverage on thin crust can feel light because the base is so thin.
Ask for extra sauce. It’s a small add-on and it makes a real difference, especially on the Classic Combo or Hot Stuff. The sauce-to-crust ratio hits different and the whole slice feels more substantial.
Insider Trick 2: Mix Two Specialties with a Half & Half
This one surprises people every time. You can get two completely different specialty pizzas on one pie — that’s our half & half pizza option. One half Taco Pie, one half Chicken Bacon Ranch. One half Hawaiian, one half Hot Stuff.
The Half & Half Specialty Pie runs $21.99–$35.99 depending on size. The Half & Half Super Specialty Pie starts at $15.99 for a small and goes up to $37.75 for a large. It’s perfect when two people want completely different things and don’t want to order two separate pies.
Most people don’t know this exists. Now you do.
Insider Trick 3: Super Taco with Extra Sour Cream Packets
The Super Taco is already stacked — taco sauce, beef, black olives, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, sour cream, cheddar, mozzarella, and extra cheddar, with one taco packet per slice. It comes with sour cream built into the pizza and taco seasoning packets on the side.
Here’s what most people don’t do: add extra sour cream packets. They’re $0.99 each and they’re worth every cent. The Super Taco is already our most loaded pie — extra sour cream takes it from “really good” to “why do I even eat regular pizza.”
Read the full Super Taco review if you want the breakdown before you order.
Insider Trick 4: Build Your Own with 5 Toppings
The build your own combos page has a full breakdown, but here’s the short version: Create Your Own starts at $7.99 for a mini and goes up to $24.75 for a large. Each topping add-on is a small upcharge, but loading up a large with five toppings still comes out cheaper than most of our specialty pies — and you pick exactly what goes on it.
The sweet spot? Pick a base specialty that’s close to what you want, then just ask to swap or add one topping instead of building from scratch. That way you’re starting from a tested combo and tweaking it, not guessing.
Insider Trick 5: Extra Cheddar on the Taco Pie
The Taco Pie is already built with cheddar and mozzarella, plus extra cheddar. But you can ask for even more cheddar on top. It’s cheap, it makes the whole pie more taco-ish, and it crisps up beautifully on the Golden Crust.
If you’re new to the Taco Pie: it’s taco sauce, beef, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and cheese — all on our Original crust, with the lettuce and tomatoes added fresh after baking so nothing gets soggy. It’s $13.99–$34.50 depending on size. It’s one of the most-ordered pies we make. See the toppings guide for more ways to customize it.
Insider Trick 6: Order Monkey Bread as a Starter
Everyone treats Monkey Bread like a dessert. It shows up at the end of the meal, everyone’s already full, and it just sits there getting cold. Wrong move.
Order it as your appetizer. The Cinnamon Monkey Bread ($7.79) is warm pull-apart sweet bread with cinnamon sugar and icing drizzle. It takes about the same time to come out as your pizza, it’s meant to be eaten hot, and it disappears fast at the table. Don’t save it for last — eat it first while it’s warm and gooey.
The Italian Monkey Bread ($7.79) works the same way as a savory starter — garlic butter, seasoned cheese, served with marinara. Order it when your pizza goes in. By the time it hits the table, you’re ready for it.
The Real Secret: Ask for What You Want
The biggest insider tip is the simplest one. We’re not a chain assembly line. When you call (210) 750-2222 or place your order online, you can tell us how you want your pizza. Extra sauce. Light cheese. Half this, half that. Specific crust. Add toppings to a specialty. We’ve heard it all.
You’re not going to offend anyone by customizing your order. That’s the whole point of the create-your-own section — and honestly, that flexibility extends to most of our menu when you just ask.
Does Godfather’s Pizza San Antonio have a secret menu?
No, there’s no secret menu with hidden items that aren’t listed anywhere. What we do have is a lot of flexibility in how you customize what’s on the menu — extra sauce, half & half pies, topping swaps, and add-ons that most people don’t know to ask for.
Can I get a half and half pizza at Godfather’s?
Yes. The Half & Half Specialty Pie lets you split two different specialty pizzas on one pie. Sizes start at small and go up to large. It’s a great move when two people want completely different things.
What comes with the Super Taco pizza?
The Super Taco comes with taco sauce, beef, black olives, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, sour cream, cheddar, mozzarella, extra cheddar, and one taco seasoning packet per slice. You can add extra sour cream packets for $0.99 each.
Can I customize a specialty pizza or add extra toppings?
Yes. You can add toppings to any specialty pizza. Just ask when you order — online or by calling (210) 750-2222. Extra toppings are a small upcharge depending on the size.
What’s the cheapest way to build a pizza at Godfather’s?
Create Your Own starts at $7.99 for a mini. You choose your crust, sauce, and toppings. For a large, you’re looking at $24.75 base before adding toppings. It’s often cheaper than a specialty pie if you’re keeping it simple.
Ready to put these tricks to use? Order online now or call us at (210) 750-2222. We’re right here on 151.
