Create Your Own lets you break from the specialty menu and build exactly the pizza you want — no compromises, no unwanted toppings, no settling. We’ve had thousands of orders come through, and we’ve noticed which custom combos people keep coming back to. Here are the ones worth trying.
How Create Your Own Works
Start with a crust — Golden, Original, or Thin — then pick your sauce, cheese, and toppings. You can load up as many toppings as you want. Prices run $7.99 to $24.75 depending on size, which makes it the most affordable way to get exactly what you’re hungry for. Check our crust options if you’ve never compared the three before — the crust choice changes the whole pizza.
The full topping roster on our full menu covers meats (pepperoni, sausage, Italian sausage, beef, ham, bacon, bacon bits, chicken, anchovies), vegetables (onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, tomatoes, jalapeños), and cheese (mozzarella, cheddar, extra cheese). You’ve got a lot to work with.
Best Meat Combos
If you want to build a meat-forward pizza without going full meat lover’s guide, these are the combinations that hit right:
Pepperoni + Italian Sausage + Mushrooms — The classic combination that shows up in pizza menus everywhere for a reason. Italian sausage is fennel-forward, pepperoni is spicy and crispy at the edges, and mushrooms soak up all that grease in the best way. Golden crust recommended. This is one of those combos you can’t go wrong with.
Bacon + Beef + Cheddar — If the Bacon Cheeseburger specialty pizza catches your eye but you want more control, build your own version. Add beef and bacon to Signature Sauce, swap out straight mozzarella for cheddar, and throw in onions if you want the full cheeseburger effect. Golden crust makes this sing. The cheddar gives it a sharpness that mozzarella alone doesn’t have.
Ham + Bacon + Pineapple — Yeah, we’re going there. The Hawaiian is a specialty pizza for a reason — sweet and salty works on pizza. Build it yourself on Thin crust if you want a lighter result, or on Golden for a richer one. Trust us on this one: if you haven’t tried it, this is the low-risk way to find out if it’s your thing.
Best Veggie Combos
Building a veggie pizza yourself lets you leave out whatever you’re not into. Our Veggie specialty has a great lineup, but some people want more tomatoes, no olives, extra mushrooms — that’s what Create Your Own is for.
Mushrooms + Green Peppers + Onions + Tomatoes — The core four. Everything plays well together. Mushrooms bring earthiness, green peppers bring brightness, onions go sweet in the oven, and tomatoes add a little acid to balance the cheese. Add extra cheese on top and call it done.
Jalapeños + Onions + Green Peppers + Tomatoes — A veggie pizza with heat. No meat needed. The jalapeños carry the whole thing. Add cheddar instead of mozzarella for more flavor punch. Thin crust keeps it from feeling too heavy, but Original holds up better if you’re going heavy on the jalapeños.
Spicy Combos
If you want something with a kick but the Hot Stuff specialty isn’t exactly what you’re looking for, build your own version. Our toppings guide goes deep on which toppings add heat and which add flavor without the burn.
Pepperoni + Italian Sausage + Jalapeños + Beef — Four of the spicier items on the topping list working together. The pepperoni crisps at the edges and adds heat. Italian sausage has that fennel spice. Jalapeños bring the actual burn. Beef is the base that holds it together. Stick with Original crust — this is a thick-crust pizza by nature.
Chicken + Jalapeños + Onions — A lighter version of spicy. Chicken is the mildest meat we carry, so the jalapeños and onions do the flavoring. If you want to keep it simple and still get some heat, this is the move. Add green peppers to round it out.
Sweet + Savory Combos
The sweet-and-savory category isn’t for everyone, but if it’s your thing, the Create Your Own menu makes it easy to try without committing to a whole specialty pizza.
Ham + Bacon Bits + Tomatoes — Salty, smoky, and bright. The tomatoes cut through the richness of the ham and bacon bits in a way that feels lighter than a pure meat pizza. Thin crust is the right call here. This is the kind of pizza that surprises people — in a good way.
Whether you’re building a comfort pizza or experimenting, Create Your Own is where you get exactly what you came for. We’ve seen just about every combination, and we haven’t made a bad one yet. Check the top 5 pizzas if you’d rather skip the building and go with what we know works — or see what makes us different from every other pizza place on this side of San Antonio.
Create Your Own — $7.99 to $24.75
Mini through Large. Choose crust (Golden, Original, Thin), sauce, cheese, and as many toppings as you want. Meats, veggies, or both — it’s your pizza.
What Size Should You Order?
Mini is 6 slices and feeds 1–2 people. Small is solid for a solo meal with leftovers. Medium feeds 2–3. Large is the move for families or groups. If you’re feeding more than four, grab two custom builds or pair a Create Your Own with a specialty pizza from the full menu. The Build Your Own Feast deals bundle two pizzas plus a side, which is often the better value at group size.
How much does Create Your Own pizza cost at Godfather’s?
Create Your Own pizzas run $7.99 to $24.75 depending on size. That range covers Mini through Large. Toppings are included in the base price, so you’re not paying extra per topping.
What crusts are available on Create Your Own?
Golden, Original, and Thin crust are all available on Create Your Own. Golden is pan-baked with a buttery bottom, Original is the thick classic crust, and Thin is lighter with a crispy edge. The crust you pick changes how the pizza eats.
Can I substitute the sauce on Create Your Own?
Yes — you choose your sauce when you build. Options include Signature Sauce, Taco Sauce, Ranch, BBQ, and Buffalo. Each one takes the pizza in a completely different direction, so pick based on the toppings you’re pairing it with.
What’s the most popular custom combo at Godfather’s?
Pepperoni and Italian sausage show up most often in custom builds, usually with mushrooms or green peppers. But the Bacon + Beef + Cheddar build is close behind — it’s essentially a custom Bacon Cheeseburger pizza that lets you add exactly what you want.
Is Create Your Own available on the Godfather’s online ordering system?
Yes — you can build your custom pizza from the online ordering link below. Select crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings, then choose your size. Pickup is available at 8530 SH 151 Access Rd, San Antonio, TX 78245.
