Super Bowl Sunday is the single biggest pizza day of the year in America, and San Antonio takes the big game seriously. Your watch party food needs to be right — and that means ordering before the rush, not at halftime. Here’s how to plan a Super Bowl pizza order that’s actually ready when the game kicks off.
We don’t make any promises about what the Spurs can do in the Super Bowl (wrong sport, wrong league — but you knew that). What we can promise is that your Super Bowl pizza order will be hot, correct, and arrive on time if you plan ahead. We’re at 8530 SH 151 Access Rd. Super Bowl Sunday is the year’s busiest night — plan accordingly.
Order Early on Super Bowl Sunday
Super Bowl Sunday hits like a wall. Every pizza shop in San Antonio gets slammed starting around noon and it doesn’t let up until well after kickoff. The only way to guarantee your order is to call ahead — ideally the day before, or early Sunday morning. Online ordering is available for standard orders, but for a large watch party order, the phone call is more reliable.
If you’re watching with a group of 20+, have your order placed and paid at least 3–4 hours before kickoff. You don’t want to be calling at 5pm when every driver in the city is already committed.
Best Pizzas for a Super Bowl Watch Party
Super Bowl parties need volume and variety. The Classic Combo and pepperoni are the anchors — everyone eats those, nobody complains. Add a specialty or two for the crowd that wants something to talk about during the commercials.
The Taco Pie is always a conversation starter at watch parties. The BBQ Chicken pizza is another crowd-pleaser that feels slightly more special than the everyday options. If your group has strong opinions on pizza (and Super Bowl groups usually do), the half-and-half option lets two people split a pie their own way.
Super Bowl Party Pizza Count
Super Bowl parties tend to have sustained eating — people graze from pregame through the end of the fourth quarter. Plan on 3 slices per person minimum, not the usual 2. For a party of 20: 60 slices = 8 large pizzas. Round up to 10 to cover the second-round eaters and the game-ending hunger surge.
The Pizza Pack (4 large pizzas for $75) makes the math easy. Two packs for a party of 20–24. Three packs for 30–35. Four packs for 40+ people. See our pizza count guide for help dialing in the right number for your specific group.
Wings for the Super Bowl
Super Bowl parties without wings aren’t Super Bowl parties — they’re just people watching football. Our wings guide covers what we offer and how to size the wing order alongside the pizza. Adding wings to a Super Bowl pizza order turns a good spread into a great one. Order both and nobody goes home wanting.
Game Day Delivery vs. Pickup
On Super Bowl Sunday, pickup is the more reliable move. Delivery is possible but the wait can stretch significantly during the peak hours before kickoff. If you can send someone to get the order, you’ll have more control over timing. Come by 8530 SH 151 Access Rd and pick it up — we’ll have it hot and ready.
Super Bowl rule: order the day before or before noon on game day. Waiting until 3–4pm means waiting in line with the rest of the city. You’ve been warned.
Do you stay open during the Super Bowl?
Yes. We’re open Super Bowl Sunday our regular hours — 11am to 9pm. The closer to kickoff, the longer the wait. Order early and pick up or receive delivery before the pregame rush.
Can I order Super Bowl pizza online?
Yes, at godfathers.orderexperience.net. For large watch party orders, calling (210) 750-2222 is more reliable so we can confirm your timing and get the order right. Online ordering works great for groups under 10 or 12 pizzas.
What’s the most popular Super Bowl pizza order?
Classic Combo and pepperoni are always the top sellers on game day. People who want to branch out go with the Taco Pie or BBQ Chicken. If you’re watching with a big group, a mix of all four hits every preference.
Lock in your Super Bowl order early. Order online or call to place your game day order.
